The best cooking vessels are those that can withstand the test of time.

For centuries, carbon steel and cast iron have been staples in people's kitchens because they provide durability and heat retention - which means you'll never need another pan!

But then Teflon came along with its easy-to-use nonstick coating making them popular among many cooks today.

However, these pans aren’t precisely durable or reliable compared to traditional materials like Carbon steel and cast iron.

In addition to being cheaper than other types of cookware too! 

So If you prefer to buy cookware made of traditional materials like carbon steel and cast iron, this blog is the best one you should not miss.

All your problems about carbon steel cookware Vs Cast Iron Cookware can be solved after reading this blog!

This blog will include the following topic:


The main difference - cast iron vs. carbon steel

Iron is an important metallic element. It is used to produce many different useful metal alloys, such as steel.

There are various types of iron alloys, including steel, wrought iron, cast iron, anthracite, etc. Cast iron consists of a large amount of carbon and is brittle. Carbon steel is a form of steel consisting of iron and carbon and traces of certain elements.

The main difference between cast iron and carbon steel is that cast iron contains 2-4% carbon, while carbon steel contains up to 1% carbon.


What is cast iron

Cast iron is a hard, more brittle alloy of iron and carbon that can be easily cast into molds.

It contains a higher percentage of carbon than steel. Cast iron is a metal alloy. The alloy has a carbon content of 2-4%. Cast iron has a lower melting temperature than other iron alloys.

Cast iron consists of silicon, manganese, and traces of sulfur and phosphorus along with carbon and iron.

 It has a high carbon content. Cast iron solidifies as a heterogeneous alloy. Cast iron also contains about 1-3% silicon.

Thus, cast iron is actually a metal alloy of iron-carbon-silicon. Molten cast iron is less reactive with molding materials. However, cast iron is not very ductile. Therefore, it is not suitable for rolling.

Type of cast iron

There are a few types of cast iron depending on the microstructure of the alloy. They are.

Gray cast iron

Ductile cast iron

Malleable cast iron

White cast iron

Due to the high carbon content, cast iron is more brittle.

Carbon tends to form carbides or graphite flakes, making cast iron more irregular and brittle.

As a result, cast iron is less ductile. It has a low strength. Due to the high iron-to-carbon ratio, cast iron also has a high weight.

What is carbon steel?

Carbon steel consists of iron and carbon. The alloying elements are present in trace amounts. Some of these elements are silicon, manganese, sulfur and phosphorus. Carbon steels are also divided into the following three groups.

Low carbon steels - up to 0.3% carbon

High carbon steels - up to 0.3-0.6% carbon

Low carbon steels - up to 1 % carbon

Mild steel has more iron than carbon. Therefore, it is highly corrosive in wet environments.

High-carbon steel is very strong and can be used as a construction material. Due to the presence of large amounts of carbon in carbon steel, it exhibits properties such as hardness, reduced ductility, reduced weldability, and low melting point.

Low-carbon steels have a carbon content of about 0.04-0.30%. Depending on the desired properties, other elements are added to improve the quality of the steel. This form is stronger than low-carbon steel, but not as strong as high-carbon steel.

Typically, carbon steels have a high degree of ductility. Carbon steels are less brittle and stronger due to the smaller amount of carbon present compared to the amount of iron present in the alloy.

A cast iron pan with a piece of meat on it

Difference between cast iron and carbon steel

  • Definition

Cast Iron: Cast iron is a hard and brittle alloy of iron and carbon that can be easily cast in a mold and has a higher carbon content than steel.

Carbon Steel: Carbon steel is steel with a high carbon content and a low content of other elements.

  • Carbon Content

Cast Iron: Cast iron contains up to 2-4% carbon.

Carbon Steel: Carbon steel contains up to 1 % carbon.

  • Strength

Cast iron: Cast iron is more brittle due to the presence of large amounts of carbon.

Carbon Steel: Carbon steel is stronger than cast iron.

  • Ductility

Cast iron: Cast iron is less ductile.

Carbon Steel: Carbon steel is more ductile.

  • Melting Point

Cast iron: Cast iron has a lower melting point.

Carbon Steel: Carbon steel has a higher melting point.

  • Other Elements

Cast Iron: Cast iron consists of iron, carbon, silicon-manganese, and traces of sulfur and phosphorus.

Carbon Steel: Carbon steel consists mainly of iron and carbon. Other elements can be present in trace amounts.

They differ from each other depending on the amount of carbon present and the other elements added to the alloy. The main difference between cast iron and carbon steel is their carbon content.

three various sizes of carbon steel pans have been put in the same location.

Carbon steel Cookware Vs Cast Iron Cookware 

Carbon Steel Cookware 

Carbon steel pots are pressed from a whole carbon steel plate, with a carbon content of about 0.02% to 2%.

Carbon steel has excellent heat conduction and heat storage, so many star-rated restaurants abroad use carbon steel pans as the basic equipment in the kitchen.

Carbon steel is lighter, safer, and more durable than cast iron.


  • Carbon steel conducts heat evenly and faster than cast iron

    Carbon steel and cast iron are both excellent choices for cookware. Carbon steel conducts heat evenly and faster than cast iron, and the reason is the higher carbon content. Carbon steel has about 2% carbon whereas cast iron has only about 1%.

    The extra carbon in the carbon steel makes it a better conductor of heat.

  • The smooth surface of the carbon steel pan makes cooking easier

    One of the most appealing features of carbon steel is its smooth surface. Unlike cast iron, which often has a rough or pebbly surface, carbon steel has a smooth surface that is easy to clean and maintain. This smooth surface also helps to prevent sticking and makes flipping and stirring foods much simpler

  • Carbon steel is about 30% lighter than cast iron, which is easy to carry

    Carbon steel is an alloy of iron and carbon, and it is this addition of carbon that makes it much lighter than cast iron. Carbon steel typically contains around 0.4-1.4% carbon, compared to cast iron which contains 2-4%.

    This difference in carbon content means that carbon steel is about 30% lighter than cast iron, making it much easier to carry and maneuver. Carbon in carbon steel provides a harder surface, which is more resistant to scratching and corrosion than cast iron.


  • It is not suitable for cooking acidic food, because its surface pores are finer than cast iron pans, so the formed oil film is easier to peel off due to improper use

  • Carbon Steel is susceptible to corrosion and rust, especially if exposed to water or kept in a humid environment. This won't ruin your Pan but will require re-seasoning.

A Pizza is on a ceramic white baking pan

Cast Iron Cookware

Cast iron contains more carbon than carbon steel, usually around 2-3.5%.

This makes the cast iron pan have a distinctive feature - a bumpy surface texture. This also makes the oil film protected on the pot surface stronger.

There are more different forms of cast iron pots, and they are also common in baking.

However, due to the high carbon content, the ductility and toughness are poor, and it is easier to break due to collisions than carbon steel pans. Because of this, cast iron pans are usually made thicker.


  • Good heat storage, but this is not necessarily an absolute advantage

    one of the main advantages of carbon steel is its superior heat storage.

    Carbon steel can reach higher temperatures than cast iron, making it ideal for searing meats or creating a crispy crust on a pizza. However, this is not necessarily an absolute advantage.

  • Through the correct use and maintenance of the pot, a stable non-stick layer will be formed

    t develops a non-stick surface when properly seasoned and maintained.

    As a result, cast iron cookware is a better choice for those who want to invest in a quality pot or pan that will last for years.


  • Since it is integrally formed, the handle is also easy to conduct heat, increasing the risk of scalding

  • The weight is too heavy than carbon steel, which is not conducive to carrying

  • Heat conduction is slower than carbon steel pans, and sometimes even uneven

  • Although thick, cast iron pans are more likely to be broken, increasing the risk of cooking

  • Like carbon steel pans, cast iron pans are not suitable for cooking acidic ingredients

Regardless of whether it is a carbon steel pot or a cast iron pot, both need to be boiled and maintained, and the conditions for acid resistance are also the same. However, compared with cast iron pans, carbon steel pans are safer and more durable in use and are lighter in weight.

The heat-resistant extended handle and more stable and balanced temperature have not only been affirmed by countless professional chefs, but also our first choice. If you don't like the appearance of cast iron pots and have a special preference for cooking methods, carbon steel pots are more suitable for home use.

Three steps for the cookware maintenance


Wash the Cast Iron cookware well 

The maintenance of cast iron and carbon steel cookware is important in order to keep it functioning well and looking its best. The first step in maintaining cast iron cookware is to wash it well. This will remove any build-up of grease or food that could cause sticking or rusting.

Be sure to use hot water and a mild detergent, and scrub the cookware with a non-abrasive sponge or brush.

It is important to avoid using harsh detergents or scouring pads, as these can damage the cookware. If the cookware begins to show signs of rust, it can be lightly sanded with steel wool or a fine-grit sandpaper.

Rinse the cookware thoroughly and dry it completely before storing it or using it again. If the cookware is not washed properly, it could rust or the food could stick, making it difficult to use. The first step in maintaining cast iron cookware, therefore, is to wash it well. 


Dry the cookware Thoroughly

After washing your cast iron cookware, it is important to dry it thoroughly to prevent rusting.

The best way to do this is to Place the pan on the stove over low heat and let it sit until all the moisture has evaporated.

You can also use a towel to dry the inside and outside of the pan.

If there is still moisture remaining, you can place the pan in a warm oven for a few minutes. Once the pan is completely dry, you can then proceed to the next step in maintenance, which is seasoning the pan. Seasoning helps to create a non-stick surface and also protects the metal from rusting.

Use oil to rub the surface of the cookware 

First, make sure that the pan is completely dry. If it is not, you can use a paper towel to dry it off.

Next, apply a thin layer of oil to the surface of the pan. You can use any type of oil, but vegetable oil or shortening are good choices.

Then, use a paper towel or clean cloth to rub the oil into the surface of the pan.

Finally, wipe away any excess oil. Once you have finished, your cookware will be ready to use.



The Best Place for You to Buy Carbon Steel or Cast Iron Cookware

In the last section of this blog, we will list some trustable cookware manufacturers for you. 

After you are clear about the difference between cast iron cookware and carbon steel cookware, We thought this list is necessary for you to save your time from choosing cookware suppliers. 




Caraway cookware is the best place to buy cookware because its products are made without any toxic materials like PFAS, PTFE, PFOA, or other chemicals.

Ceramic’s naturally slick surface means minimal oil or butter for slide-off-the-pan eggs and easy cleaning.

Caraway cookware is also designed with the home cook in mind, making it the best place to buy cookware for anyone who loves to cook.



Lodge Cast Iron is one of the oldest and most respected manufacturers of cookware in the United States.

The company was founded in 1896 and has been based in South Pittsburg, Tennessee since its inception.

Lodge cast iron cookware is known for its durability and versatility.

It can be used on all kinds of cooking surfaces, including stovetops, ovens, grills, and campfires.

The cookware is also affordable and easy to find; it is sold in most major retailers. In addition to its cookware, Lodge Cast Iron also manufactures a line of accessories, including pans, skillets, Dutch ovens, bakeware, and more.

The company embraces its legacy and strives to do the right thing for its employees, the community, and the environment.

When you buy Lodge Cast Iron products, you can rest assured that you are getting high-quality cookware that will last for generations.



If you're looking for the best place to buy cookware, Calphalon is the obvious choice.

Founded in 1963, Calphalon has been at the forefront of the cookware industry, innovating new and better ways to help home chefs create delicious meals. Among their many accomplishments, Calphalon is credited with inventing hard-anodized aluminum cookware in 1968.

This process makes cookware more durable and resistant to corrosion and warping, and it quickly became a favorite among professional chefs.

Today, Calphalon continues to lead the way in cookware innovation, offering a wide range of high-quality products that are sure to make your time in the kitchen more enjoyable. So whether you're a beginner or a seasoned pro, Calphalon is the best place to buy cookware.

8 piece of pizza on the table with two bottle of Wine around


Le Creuset

If you're looking for the best place to buy cookware, Le Creuset should be at the top of your list. Not only do they offer a 14-day return policy for a refund, but all of their cookware comes with a lifetime guarantee.

Their casseroles are made from recycled iron and steel, and each one is unique.

The pots are sprayed with enamel and then hand-finished, resulting in a product that is both beautiful and durable. In addition, Le Creuset offers free delivery on all orders over £50, making it the perfect place to find your next kitchen investment piece.


Cuisinart was founded in 1973 by the late Carl Sontheimer and is now under management from Conair Corporation.

The company produces a wide array of products that are favored by chefs and consumers alike. A key focus for Cuisinart is culinary education, which they pursue through partnering with various educational and charitable causes.

Cuisinart has won many awards throughout the years in recognition of its innovative and top-quality products. Products can be purchased through retailers both online and in-store globally.

The best place to buy cookware is at a trusted retailer like Cuisinart.

Not only will you find the best selection of products, but you can also rest assured that you're getting high-quality items that will last for years to come. When it comes to cookware, there's no better place to shop than Cuisinart.


Mosen is the best place to buy cookware.

They sell quality kitchen tools at honest prices by cutting out retail middlemen and selling directly to customers online.

Misen carefully researches and selects premium materials for optimal performance in their products. Misen obsesses over every aspect of each tool they make, from the millimeters mattering to testing each product multiple times before release.

The name "Mosen" is pronounced "mee-zen" and is derived from the culinary term 'mise en place, meaning "to put in place".

When you buy from Mosen, you can be confident that you're getting high-quality products that will perform beautifully in your kitchen.


If you're looking for the best place to buy cookware, Mauviel is a perfect choice. Founded in 1830 by Mr. Ernest Mauviel in Villedieu-les-Poêles, Normandy, Mauviel has a rich tradition of copper manufacturing that has been passed down for generations.

This gives them the strength and foundation to provide high-quality products to professional and commercial markets. Today, these same products are available to household cooks as well. With 1,000 different products available

Mauviel offers several ranges of cookware made from copper, stainless steel, or aluminum that are designed to meet the needs of both professional and amateur chefs alike. So if you're looking for the best cookware on the market, Mauviel is a perfect choice.


GreenPan is the best place to buy cookware.

The company offers a wide range of products, including the Thermolon™ (a ceramic nonstick), Magneto™ (an induction base), Evershine™ (stainless steel that stays stainless), and more.

GreenPan also has a recycling program to help sustain the environment. All of GreenPan's products are made from healthy and environmentally friendly materials, and the company has over 150 patents. Whether you're looking for the best place to buy cookware or the best place to recycle your old cookware, GreenPan is the best choice.


In 1954, Ted and Martha Nierenberg founded Dansk to bring Scandinavian design to the American market.

Dansk is known for its clean, considered designs for the kitchen, table, and home. Over the decades, they have released many popular collections.

Today, Dansk is one of the best places to buy cookware. Their products are stylish and functional, and they offer a wide range of prices to suit any budget.

Whether you're looking for a new set of pots and pans or just a few small accessories, Dansk is sure to have something to suit your needs. So if you're looking for quality cookware with a Danish twist, be sure to check out Dansk today. We're sure you won't be disappointed!


If you're looking for the best place to buy cookware, then Suncity is a perfect choice.

We've been focusing on non-stick bakeware for about 30 years, which makes us an innovative, effective and professional expert.

We strive to offer qualified products and attentive service that exceeds our customer's expectations.

Our Partners include Meyer and Walmart. So you can be sure that you're getting high-quality cookware when you shop with us.

Plus, we offer a wide range of products to choose from, so you're sure to find the perfect set of pots and pans for your needs. So why wait? Shop with Suncity today!


If you’re in the market for new cookware, you may be wondering whether carbon steel or cast iron is the right choice for you.

Both have their advantages and disadvantages, which we’ve outlined in this blog post.

In general, carbon steel is best for those who want lighter cookware that is easier to handle, while cast iron is better suited for those who don’t mind a little extra weight and want their cookware to last a lifetime.

No matter which type of cookware you choose, be sure to follow the three steps for proper maintenance outlined in this blog post to get the most out of your investment. Ready to start shopping?

Visit our online store today and take advantage of our current sale on carbon steel frying pans. 

Contact us if you have any questions!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Chat Online